Tobey Maguire unexpectedly became a trending topic during Super Bowl LX after he was spotted in the VIP section at Levi’s Stadium on Sunday, February 8. While the evening centered on football’s biggest stage, much of the online conversation shifted to the actor’s appearance alongside model and social media influencer Mishka Silva.
The 50-year-old Spider-Man star was photographed sitting next to Silva, who is 20 years old. Images circulating on social media showed the two appearing relaxed and in good spirits during the game. In some photos, Silva was seen smiling and playing with her hair, at one point resting her legs on the headrest of a nearby seat. Although there were no overt displays of affection, their seating arrangement was enough to ignite widespread speculation about their relationship.
The primary focus of online discourse quickly turned to the couple’s age difference. Several social media users commented on the 30-year age gap, with some noting that Maguire’s daughter, Ruby — born in 2006 — is close in age to Silva. The comparisons fueled criticism and sparked debate across platforms.
One user wrote that they were surprised by reports of the pairing, while another suggested discomfort with the visible age gap. Others pointed out that Silva was not yet born when the first Spider-Man film starring Maguire was released in 2002.
You'd think this is Tobey Maguire and his daughter at the Super Bowl, but it’s his 20 year old girlfriend. She wasn’t even born when the first Spider-Man movie came out. I have clothing in my closet older than her. pic.twitter.com/L1ZgwsB28c
— ɴᴏ ᴄᴜᴛs ɴᴏ ʙᴜᴛs ɴᴏ ᴄᴏᴄᴏɴᴜᴛs (@damn_elle) February 10, 2026
Silva later shared moments from her Super Bowl outing on Instagram, posting a series of photos captioned, “Super bowl weekend was so good i forgot to take photos, thank you @raisingcanes.” Notably, Maguire did not appear in the images she shared. Born in 2005, Silva has modeled for brands including Guess, Steve Madden, Too Faced, and Smashbox.
Maguire was previously married to jewelry designer Jennifer Meyer. The couple separated in 2016 and finalized their divorce in 2020. They share two children: daughter Ruby, 19, and son Otis, 16. Following his divorce, Maguire was linked to model Tatiana Dieteman for three years before their reported split in 2022. In 2024, he was also photographed with model and actress Lily Chee, sparking additional dating rumors.
As of now, neither Maguire nor Silva has publicly addressed the speculation surrounding their Super Bowl appearance.