When Indian cinema began, films were silent because technology was limited.
Today, when sound design and dialogue systems are highly advanced, choosing to make a silent film naturally raises questions. Why silence now?
Gandhi Talks is not a silent film in the style of Charlie Chaplin or Mr. Bean. There is no physical comedy, no exaggerated movements meant only to make people laugh. Instead, the film follows the lives of three characters who keep crossing each other’s paths, sometimes knowingly, sometimes by chance.
The story revolves around Mahadev (Vijay Sethupathi), an unemployed man struggling to find work, and Bosman (Arvind Swami), a wealthy businessman whose empire is slowly collapsing. Their meeting gives rise to an idea that could change both their lives. The third important character is a small-time pickpocket played by Siddharth Jadhav, who keeps entering and exiting their world.
The film deals with many emotions — poverty, helplessness, family, love, ambition, and survival. Yet, there are no spoken dialogues. This silence can confuse viewers, especially those expecting clear explanations through words.
Director Kishor Pandurang Belekar seems to suggest that in today’s world, words often carry less power than money. The title Gandhi Talks feels ironic — Gandhi’s face is everywhere, on currency notes and campaigns, but his ideas rarely “speak” in real life. Decisions are made quietly, without discussion, where money decides outcomes.
The film communicates largely through visuals, expressions, and background score. However, some sections may feel unclear to the audience, especially the WhatsApp text conversations that appear briefly and disappear quickly. The climax feels stretched and could have been tighter. A long sequence set inside Bosman’s luxurious house slightly drags the narrative.
Vijay Sethupathi once again delivers a natural and believable performance as a poor, desperate man. Siddharth Jadhav fits well into the role of a petty thief. Arvind Swamy convincingly portrays a businessman watching his power slip away. Aditi Rao Hydari performs her part with grace.
A.R. Rahman’s music plays a crucial role, almost acting as a voice for the film. Initially, adjusting to a story told only through music and visuals is challenging, but as the film progresses, the background score becomes an emotional guide. The songs blend into the narrative but are not particularly memorable.
Gandhi Talks has emotion, drama, and even moments of humour — yet it refuses to use dialogue. While the film sometimes drifts away from its core idea and may test the patience of viewers, the experiment itself deserves appreciation. Making a silent film with mainstream actors is a bold choice.
This film may not appeal to everyone. But for viewers open to experimental cinema and symbolic storytelling, Gandhi Talks offers an unusual and thought-provoking experience.
Film: Gandhi Talks
Director: Kishor Pandurang Belekar
Cast: Vijay Sethupathi, Arvind Swamy, Aditi Rao Hydari, Siddharth Jadhav
Music: A. R. Rahman
Running Time: 130 minutes
Gandhi Talks
2.5